Place to Stay

Shelter Island Places to Stay

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of Places to Stay in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
The Pridwin Hotel

8.7 / 10

(70 Reviews)

 From 334$
Sunset Beach

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 596$
Taber Inn

9.2 / 10

(1846 Reviews)

 From 149$
Montauk Manor

9.0 / 10

(1263 Reviews)

 From 157$
Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

8.6 / 10

(1668 Reviews)

 From 109$

Best Accommodation in Shelter Island

Table of contents

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool! Sandpoint By Rove Travel - 6Br Family Home With Pool Sunset Beach Luxury Places to Stay in Shelter Island Haven On Glynn By Rove Travel - Coastal Luxury Taber Inn Montauk Manor 5 Star Accommodation in Shelter Island Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area Old Town Inn Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

View all photos

8.7
Excellent
70 Reviews

The Pridwin Hotel

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 81 Shore Road

From 334$

Check Availability

View all photos

10
Excellent
1 Reviews

Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!

📍 78 S Ram Island Dr
Check Availability

View all photos

10
Excellent
1 Reviews

Sandpoint By Rove Travel - 6Br Family Home With Pool

📍 Brander Parkway 13
Check Availability

Luxury Places to Stay in Shelter Island

View all photos

8.2
Very good
8 Reviews

Sunset Beach

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 35 Shore Road

From 596$

Check Availability

View all photos

Haven On Glynn By Rove Travel - Coastal Luxury

📍 16 Glynn Drive
Check Availability

Hotels in Shelter Island

Best Price Hotel 🤑 The Pridwin Hotel
Best mid-range Hotel 🌴 Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
Family Hotel 👪 Sandpoint By Rove Travel - 6Br Family Home With Pool

View all photos

9.2
Excellent
1846 Reviews

Taber Inn

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 66 Williams Ave

From 149$

Check Availability

5 Star Accommodation in Shelter Island

View all photos

9
Excellent
1263 Reviews

Montauk Manor

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 236 Edgemere Street

From 157$

Check Availability

View all photos

8.6
Excellent
1668 Reviews

Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 2049 Norwich-New London Turnpike

From 109$

Check Availability

View all photos

9.7
Excellent
220 Reviews

Old Town Inn

📍 508 Old Town Road

From 155$

Check Availability

4 Star Accommodation in Shelter Island

View all photos

8.8
Excellent
939 Reviews

Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 5 Watson Road

From 119$

Check Availability

View all photos

8.4
Very good
1846 Reviews

New Haven Hotel

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 229 George Street

From 63$

Check Availability

View all photos

9
Excellent
554 Reviews

Montauk Blue Hotel

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 108 South Emerson Avenue

From 130$

Check Availability

3 Star Accommodation in Shelter Island

View all photos

9.6
Excellent
98 Reviews

King-Bed Room With Private Bath -Free Wifi-- New London-Mystic

📍 239 Williams Street

From 140$

Check Availability

View all photos

8.2
Very good
2601 Reviews

Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 411 Norwich Westerly Rd

From 144$

Check Availability

View all photos

8.8
Excellent
1123 Reviews

Mohegan Sun

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 1 Mohegan Sun Boulevard

From 239$

Check Availability

Cheap Accommodation in Shelter Island

View all photos

8.7
Excellent
496 Reviews

Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 2255 Norwich New London Turnpike

From 99$

Check Availability

View all photos

8.1
Very good
1528 Reviews

Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 1954 Norwich New London Tpke

From 99$

Check Availability

View all photos

8.7
Excellent
550 Reviews

Hyatt Place Mystic

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 224 Greenmanville Ave

From 114$

Check Availability

Location